Masters Of Song Fu #4: Round 1 Challenge Voting Begins!

songfu2.jpg

We here at Quick Stop Entertainment are true lovers of music, in all its forms. We’re also quite keen on the spirit of competition, and of spurring creativity through said competition.

To that end, we launched a unique form of creative combat here at the Stop.

In this age of manufactured and painfully earnest talent contests, we’ve decided to instead shine a light on the quirky, quixotic underworld of musicians that don’t get nearly the attention they deserve.

Ah, but I did mention that there was a competition involved…

Like a songwriting version of Iron Chef, the competitors will be presented with a very specific songwriting challenge. They’ll be given one week to complete their songs – however they see fit, within the parameters set forth – after which time the entries will be uploaded to Quick Stop to be voted on by you, the audience.

Oh, and what do we call this competition?

MASTERS OF SONG FU

lucyline.gif

Let us not forget the very special Masters of MASTERS OF SONG FU. Think of them as the iron chefs of Song Fu – one of which will be revealed as the ultimate challenger in THE FINAL CHALLENGE. Past Masters have included Jonathan Coulton, Paul & Storm, Neil Innes, The RiffTones, and Garfunkel & Oates. Any one of them could be the Master in the final Challenge – or perhaps it could be a brand new Master. Only the Challenger who garners the most cumulative votes in all 3 Challenges will move on to the Final and face that Master, mano a mano.

As with the last edition of Song Fu, all of the Challengers will be able to compete in every Challenge, and the Challenger with the most cumulative votes after the 3 Challenges will be the one that takes on the Master in the Final Round. So what was the first Challenge?

lucyline.gif

ROUND 1 CHALLENGE

Write a song from the perspective of an inanimate object. This inanimate object must have no moving parts. Also no computers, no objects that look like living things, either human or animal (i.e. a statue, an action figure, etc.), and no celestial objects (i.e. the sun or the moon). Your song can be in any style you choose.

That’s it. The only other directive is that your song must run no shorter than 1 minute 45 seconds.

lucyline.gif

THE CHALLENGERS

MOLLY LEWIS

When she’s not bluffing her way through college courses or looking passably attractive from a distance, Molly Lewis enjoys playing ukulele, microwaving marshmallow Peeps, talking to cats, and Twittering. Early last year, she wrote two original songs, “MyHope” and “Road Trip”. “MyHope” is about the inevitable day when our children will learn how to navigate the interweb and how they will LOL at our old internet presences, namely MySpace; of “Road Trip”, Molly says it’s about “that astronaut lady who went crazy and wore the diapers, you remember that?” She has not written any songs since. Hopefully this competition will remedy that. When Molly was in middle school, she took up the guitar. That sank into the swamp. So she took up the mandolin. That sank into the swamp. So she took up the banjo. That burned down, fell over, then sank into the swamp. But the ukulele has stayed. And that’s what you’re going to get, Quick Stop Entertainment: the strongest ukulele in all of Tacoma, Washington. Molly defeated Masters Paul & Storm in Masters of Song Fu #3.

Official Website: www.sweetafton23.com/primer/
Twitter: twitter.com/Molly23
ROUND 1 SONG: Unfortunately, Molly was cornered by retaliatory dingoes sent by Paul & Storm, and was unable to compete in this Challenge.

EDRIC HALEEN

songfu-edrichaleen.jpgEdric has been writing music (off and on) since the early nineties. He wrote and directed a musical, The Pushcart War, based on Jean Merrill’s wonderful novel. He has written and/or arranged a number of songs for various friends – some commissioned, some as surprises. He loves acting in community theatre, and is inspired by the music of Stephen Sondheim, Jason Robert Brown, Adam Guettel, Lynn Ahrens and Stephen Flaherty. He is also happy to finally return his Happiness Board to the Internet. Check out the link on his web pages.

Official Website: happinessboard.com/Edric_Haleen.html
ROUND 1 SONG:All For This Moment

“BUCKETHAT” BOBBY MATHESON

songfu-buckethatbobby.jpgI’m “BucketHat” Bobby Matheson. I used to make cartoons for the internet, and sometimes still do, but mostly focus on my music right now. Lately, I’ve been getting more into recording other singer/songwriters in my little, make-shift studio than I have been recording myself. I want Masters Of Song Fu to change that. I don’t really know what genre my music would fall under. Influences range from Klezmer to folk, to punk and back, which ends up sounding more like Zydeco than anything else (who’d have guessed?). I’ve been thinking of dropping the “BucketHat” from my stagename, but fear change.

Official Website: www.buckethatbobby.randomsociety.com
Twitter: twitter.com/BucketHatBobby
ROUND 1 SONG:Noose

MIKE LOMBARDO

Mike Lombardo is a piano-playing pop-rock singer-songwriter who likes to use hyphens when describing his occupation. A recent graduate of Berklee College of Music, he spends most of his time banging on pianos, teaching children how to bang on pianos, or playing shows with his band, the Mike Lombardo Trio. Feel free to go to his website and send him lots of money. Or cookies.

Official Website: www.mikelombardomusic.com
Twitter: twitter.com/mikelombardo
ROUND 1 SONG:Rock Song

GöDZ PööDLZ

Legendz foretell of a mighty duo, born in the frozen North. Two neighborz and friendz will unite to form “Gödz Pöödlz” and battle the Mazterz or Song Fu for glory and bragging rightz! Gödz Pöödlz are Rüss Rögers and Röd Dürre. Rüss Rögers was once a member of “Kit and Kaboodle” (still available on iTunes) and currently performs in “Rusty’s Rocking Jamboree!” Röd Dürre wrote and performed with the Goth Rock Godz “Sear”, and last year Röd won the Coor’s Light “Take the 4:53 to Happy Hour” songwriting contest! Remember, the heaviest of metals are soft!

Official Website: www.rockingjamboree.com
ROUND 1 SONG:Bad Penny

STEVE CHATTERTON

songfu-stevechatterton.pngHi, my name is Steve Chatterton, the quintessential one-man-band singer/songwriter net-based recording project. Mom always said I marched to the sound of a different drummer, but she never mentioned which one. Dad had a fondness for bagpipes. Fortunately, neither of them have any direct influence on my music. Specializing in quirky little guitar-oriented pop songs about bugs, the Scooby gang, pirates, palindromes, superheroes, old movies, infectious diseases, imaginary friends and sideshow freaks, I guess you could say I pretty much write love songs. I’m a cheesy bastard at heart. I’m a stay-at-home dad who’s looking to find more time in the studio when my youngest starts school in September. I have an ever-expanding back catalog (at least 3 albums worth & counting) I’m dying to share with the world one download at a time.

Official Website: www.stevechatterton.com
Twitter: twitter.com/SteveChatterton
ROUND 1 SONG:I Will Always Look Up To You

JUTZE SCHULT

Johannes “Jutze” Schult (from Germany) likes to live in a dream world where there has been no Grunge and where he is a talented singer. Sometimes his little folky pop songs find their way into the real world. Here they suffer from his hoarse voice and the do-it-yourself home recording production, struggling to appeal off and on beaten musical paths.

Official Website: www.jutze.com
Twitter: twitter.com/schult
ROUND 1 SONG:Natalie Portman’s Doormat

JARRETT HEATHER

Although he has no formal training, Jarrett is an accomplished pianist who has been composing music for nearly twenty years. A relative newcomer to the world of online amateur competitive songwriting, he burst onto the scene earlier this year when he filled out an entry form just before the deadline. While earning his living as a graphic artist and website developer, Jarrett secretly dreams of leaving behind the glamor and prestige of internet publishing so he can focus on composing music for songwriting contests full-time. With no fanbase, loyal followers, obedient minions or friends, Jarrett will rely on his music-crafting skills alone to win over converts and earn votes.

Official Website: www.spaceparanoids.net
Twitter: twitter.com/SpaceParanoids
ROUND 1 SONG:Trapped Inside Your Sofa

AUDIOMOHEL

Forged in the furnace of irony, molded with the hammer of satire, flattened on the anvil of righteousness, and cooled in the water of awesomeness, AudioMohel was thrust upon the world. Named from the lost audio transcripts of ’09, AudioMohel serves as a public-service backlash against the anti-circumcision trend sweeping the so-called “enlightened parents” crowd, AudioMohel urges their more devoted and impressionable fans to undergo the snip two or even three times. AudioMohel enjoys experimenting with new breakthrough genres like speed blues and death classical even though most of AudioMohel’s tunes reside firmly in the ethereal realm of vapor-ware. Some of AudioMohel’s members admitted to being a bit intimidated by the professed experience and actual musical talent apparently possessed by the Song Fu Masters, but finally it was decided that if the need arose, sabotage would not be out of the question. To be used as a last resort, naturally, but not out of the question.

Official Website: www.AudioMohel.com
Twitter: twitter.com/AudioMohel
ROUND 1 SONG:Hubcap Without A Home

JALEPENO HABANEROS

In the far off land of Chandler, Arizona, where the rivers flow with sand and cacti, our leader and master, the Lord of Our Lady Gwynyth, guitar and microphone in hand, called for the greatest musicians in the land to assemble a rock and roll group like none other. Unfortunately, they were cut off on the road, and the Jalapeño Habañeros made it there first. With The Rogue Bohemian on saxophone and The Boxcar Bassist on bass and keyboards, the Lord was pleased. Now, they roam the streets of Chandler, playing epic songs and rocking faces, much like Bon Jovi. Unfortunately they are paid in change, and often get thrown into the street, also like Bon Jovi. Their lives have intertwined, and the era of the Jalapeño Habañeros has begun. Be prepared.

Official Website: None
ROUND 1 SONG:Aquaman’s Trident’s Lament

THE SCRIBBLES

The Scribbles are one of the most popular ukulele-based trios in their entire 6th grade class. Oh sure, there is the rumor that Peter Choi hates them. Meh. He’s a hater. Ha ha. The Scribbles formed last November when they all agreed on the name. After that they bought some instruments and started writing songs and stuff. So far, they’ve played a handful of shows around their hometown of Springfield, MO. Everyone’s favorite song seems to be “The Robot Song”. Maybe it’s because robots really are taking over the world, or maybe because Connor wears the robot suit during that song and that’s pretty funny. Thanks to MySpace, they are now friends with really cool people like The Beatles and Weezer and Tom. They’ve said some really nice things like “iloveyouguys:D” and “thanx for the add:).” Oh, and by the way, Peter Choi, The Scribbles still luv u.

Official Website: www.myspace.com/thescribbles1
ROUND 1 SONG:Snuggie Like Me

GORBZILLA

songfu-gorbzilla.pngGorbzilla is a musician/band teacher in Mid-Michigan. He has been in a few bands over the years, most notably as the bass player/vocalist for the band “Satin Jones” and the guitarist/vocalist for the band “Jimmy Likes Pie”. The proud father of two future rock maniacs, Gorbzilla has been writing music for the past twenty years, and is currently working on his first musical Beer ““ Finally a Musical for Men based on the Haiku by Patrick “Horkmeister” Sweet entitled, “I Think I Threw Up”. He has been happily married for eight years, and is looking forward to this competition.

Official Website: gorbzilla.blogspot.com
ROUND 1 SONG:I Am Your Pants

DARRELL MacLAINE

Darrell Maclaine has been devouring comedy songs and interesting music ever since he was old enough to know better, and is taking part in this competition essentially as penance for the amount of free music he has obtained via the previous rounds. He plays piano and keyboard bass as one fifth of oddball UK pop group The Directors (another fifth of the group, Mathew Cornah, possesses both more instrumental expertise and a much better home studio than him and will inevitably be press-ganged into contributing to his entries), and has decided to exercise his rusty songwriting muscles in the most embarrassingly public way possible.

Official Website: directors.mashedbins.com
ROUND 1 SONG:Strawberry Fool

BERG AND JERRY

Berg and Jerry are a small suburban acoustic group comprised of Andrew Berg (Lead Vocals, Melodica and, maybe, eventually the Ukulele) and Jerry Geleff (Guitar and Backup Vocals). Mid-summer ’08, Berg and Jerry began writing songs together and since then… well, basically nothing. As rookies to this competition, these guys hope to at least make one good song, and entertain at least one person (*fingers crossed*). Berg and Jerry have a fun ska/indie/punk acoustic sound and often try to write clever witty lyrics. So listen, laugh, and something else that starts with an “L”, because Berg and Jerry are ready to slightly attempt to be THE MASTERS OF SONG FU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Official Website: www.myspace.com/bergandjerry
ROUND 1 SONG:The Green Potato Chip Song

DERREK J. THOMPSON

Derrek J. Thompson is an irresponsible and unimportant song-writer and all-around creative type that lives in the middle of nowhere. His hobbies include sleeping and performing Bach at old-folks homes. He plays keyboards in a band called Anthropophobia but they don’t seem to be going anywhere. He hopes to become more disciplined with his creative endeavors as a result of Song Fu.

Official Website: www.derrekswords.com/
ROUND 1 SONG:O’Riely’s Underpants

JEREMY PIERSON

Jeremy’s turn-ons include big eyes, belly laughter, and long walks on the beach. Turn-offs include bad breath, knobby knees, and fungal growth. Huh? This isn’t my post for eHarmony.com? Oh. It’s for what? “Song Fu”? What’s that? I voluntarily submitted to participate? I’ve participated before? Oh. That. I didn’t get any votes last time? Oh, only a few? How many is “a few”? Eight? Why am I participating again? The challenge of it all and the friendly competition? Just to be considered, however briefly, a peer of Jonathan Coulton? Sweet.

Official Website: www.jeremypierson.com
ROUND 1 SONG:Your Welcome Mat

DENISE HUDSON

Denise lived in a grey house in the city of Austin. Her favorite pastimes were playing piano, polishing her guitar, and tormenting the geeky programmer boy who lived there. His name was Michael, but she never called him that… Isn’t that a wonderful bio???

Official Website: www.myspace.com/denisehudson
ROUND 1 SONG:Leave The Stone Alone, Yep

LEX VADER

Lex Vader was born to a single mother who worked as silicon tycoon’s personal assistant. When she died of poor hygiene, Lex was sent to an orphanage where he showed interest in organizing races and laser fencing. After being recruited into a religious order, he spent the next few years between several of their private schools. In his final year, Lex lost his hand in an argument with a professor over Kryptochlorians. Despite this, Lex was able to achieve a successful business career and even a knighthood. Tragedy struck, however, when a former classmate’s arctic home caught fire during a business lunch, scarring half of Lex’s face. At this point, Lex’s behavior became erratic. When he managed to buy SithCo, the cult that schooled him, he was shunned by the corporate world. No longer taken seriously, Lex started an evil empire and now moonlights with his evil emotronic alternapop band.

Official Website: lexvaderssecretjournal.wordpress.com
ROUND 1 SONG:Just A Rock

TOM MILSOM

Tom Milsom is a musician, writer, artist and videomaker who has had nearly 2,000,000 views of his YouTube videos and has released an album, Awkward Ballads for the Easily Pleased, to murmurs of critical success. Faced with this onslaught of vague acceptance, he plans to release his second album, Painfully Mainstream, later this year, and is thrilled to be a part of this frankly charming and delightful competition.

Official Website: www.tommilsom.com
ROUND 1 SONG:The Raincoat’s Lament

CALEB HINES

Caleb became a software engineer instead of a musician because the type of music he likes best went out of style at the end of the 18th century. Self-taught in music theory, he is more comfortable writing a four-part instrumental fugue than he is writing a verse-chorus-bridge song. After discovering the likes of Weird Al, Dr. Horrible, and especially Jonathan Coulton, he realized that “modern music” can be fun too. Now he is on a quest to update, expand, and diversify his musical knowledge and experience. In addition to singing, he plays a whole family of recorders (not usually all at once) and baroque flute, pretends to play keyboard, and most recently, ukulele. He also uses virtual MIDI instruments because a real orchestra costs too much.

Official Website: NONE
ROUND 1 SONG:Ancient Wonder

MILES FROM NASHVILLE

Miles from Nashville was born in early 2009 when multi-instrumentalist Charlie Wolf and harmonica player Michael Ruhland ran into each-other one day at the Albertson’s supermarket in Hermosa Beach, CA. Miles from Nashville play an eclectic mix of country, folk, rock, blues, pop, indie rock, rap (just kidding), and polka that they like to call “guacamole rock”. They are currently working on their debut album, Songs about November, and have their very own website (though who doesn’t these days?). If you happen to have large sums of money and/or expensive guitars that you don’t need, they’ll be glad to put them to use for you. Miles from Nashville plays shows around Los Angeles, CA every so often, so be sure to check the website for gigs.

Official Website: www.milesfromnashville.com
ROUND 1 SONG:A Bridge To Nowhere

ANDREW THOMSON

Hello. I am singer-songwriter, multi-instrumentalist, filmmaker, writer and activist Andrew Jon Thomson. I am honored to have played, collaborated, performed, and recorded with many outstanding musicians from many fantastic bands including the following current and past collaborators: The Memphis Horns, Dweezil Zappa, Anton Fig, Chuck Rainey, Tom Roady, Charlie Chalmers, Roades Chalmers Roades, Arthur Barrow, Walfredo Reyes Jr., Tommy Mars, Clayton Ivey, Charlie Morgan, Pablo Herrera (Cuba), Richard Nelson (Ireland), Mike Garson, Pat Mastellotto, Marc Muller, Rob Paporozzi, Sammy Merendino, Graham Maby, Paul Robinson (UK), Paul C. Robinson (US), Pete Lockett (UK),Victor Indrizzo, Fima Ephron, Dave “Fuze” Fiuczynski, Bassy B Brockman, David Gilmore, Victor Damiani, Todd Roper, Greg Brown, and DJ Qbert.

Official Website: www.helloandrew.com
ROUND 1 SONG:Someplace 2 Land: Bush’s Flight Suit’s Lament

CALEB LEE

To Whom It May Concern: Caleb didn’t want to write his own bio (musicians, eh?) so I will do the honours. After peddling his wares leading the criminally unnoticed Yay For Squares (www.myspace.com/yayforsquares) and playing an inadvisable amount of shows alongside good friends The Tastydactyls, Caleb decided to go solo in the early parts of 2008. Since then he’s enjoyed the success of dozens of fans and casual mentions on low-brow podcasts. With a flair for heartfelt song-writing and a wildly erotic combover, he’s hoping to win your love in this competition and will be wildly neurotic about it until he does so. – His bud, Aaron.

Official Website: www.myspace.com/caleblee
Twitter: twitter.com/thecaleblee
ROUND 1 SONG:How Man Years Bad Luck If You Break A Mirror’s Heart

RICHARD CLAYTON SPRING

Hailing from a small town in Southern Minnesota, Richard Clayton Spring has risen above the norm, blossoming into a beautiful butterfly of acoustic guitars, pianos, synths, electronic beats, and vocals ranging from the softest of whispers to the yelp of the Great Wolf. The only style of music Richard can’t write incredibly is generic pop music, or else he would be in a limousine drinking champagne with Lady GaGa. But he has acquired an auto-tuner, so he’s working his way there.

Official Website: www.myspace.com/richardclaytonspring
ROUND 1 SONG:Crazy Straw

SARA PARSONS

Parsons is a 20-year-old student from California. She can leap small buildings in a few bounds. She fears large fish, but for some reason not sharks or whales. Parsons always makes the same New Year’s resolution: to survive to see the next year. So far, this has worked well for her. Parsons comes from an impressive songwriting pedigree: her older brother wrote the song “Blue Moon” in 1934, managing to overcome his crippling dyslexia and the fact that the song was written 51 years before his birth. Parsons’s songwriting influences include Beethoven, The Beatles, and Weird Al. Her sense of humor comes from The Simpsons, Mystery Science Theater 3000, and her frequent injections of concentrated doses of Vitamin K. Parsons hopes to go far in this competition. If she doesn’t emerge victorious, she will be forced to turn to Operation Omega. Nobody wants that to happen.

Official Website: www.youtube.com/user/sargeantketchup
ROUND 1 SONG:Throw Me Away

AUSTIN & THE PUDAKS

With only two members, the name may be misleading, but that seems to be a theme here. Austin Morley and Jeremy Pudak have been playing music together for several years now, and have never really settled on a genre or a name. In their younger days they would draw on rock influences like Rancid or The Ramones. In recent years, they have settled into slightly quieter influences like She & Him and Bob Dylan. Jeremy has always had a talent for the guitar, but Austin was not so lucky and decided to stick with a bass guitar. Austin & The Pudaks will be rocking your face off, but may not actually be in a rock genre. Be careful, as exposure to this amount of awesome has unpredictable effects.

Official Website: www.myspace.com/nodirectionhome89
ROUND 1 SONG:A Record Of Your Life

IAN & MELISSA

Melissa and Ian are two amateur musicians with a longtime love of composing and performing classical music. Whether this is useful or relevant for a songwriting competition remains to be seen. They are eagerly awaiting the “Write a song in the style of an obscure Baroque composer” round, ’cause somebody totally told them there would be such a round and why would someone lie like that?

Official Website: www.ianandmelissa.com
ROUND 1 SONG:I Remember

TRAVIS NORRIS

Over the twelve years since young-ish midwesterner Travis Norris first picked up a guitar, he has played and written music in a wide variety of genres ranging from rock that a-billies, metal of a medium or heavier weight, “outlaw” country (aka “the good kind”) and “frosty” jazz (not a real subgenre). Left to his own devices, something like “U2 meets Jonny Lang meets various two-to-three-hit-wonder bands of the ’90s indie/alternative scene” is what you’ll usually get. Travis’s instrumental talents range from lead guitar, 2nd lead guitar, rhythm guitar, auxiliary guitar, and bass (sorta). He can also drag and drop drum loops like you wouldn’t believe. He comes to this competition armed with three electric guitars, a neglected bass, an Ebow, and absolutely no fan base or public recognition. So be nice, eh? I hear he’s real sensitive when people that aren’t him make fun of him.

Official Website: NONE
ROUND 1 SONG:Enertronic Bow

THE GREMLINS

When we’re not turning scrap metal into transportation and weaponry suited to post-apocalyptic life, studying the obsolete sociopolitical establishment of the twenty-first century under the guise of civil service, or scouting subterranean wilds for a suitable base of operations, The Gremlins are dedicated to sabotaging the destructive technological forces that have become your way of life through whatever mischief is at our disposal. Banjos are fun, too.

Official Website: NONE
ROUND 1 SONG:Neutron Star

THE PERFECT PLACE

When two musicians marry one another, it’s a wonderful thing. When a multi-instrumental songwriter marries an amazing vocalist, it’s even better. Bud (oldest of three, one insane sibling of each gender) was born and raised in sunny San Diego, CA ““ a drummer first, guitarist second, and just about everything you could imagine third through last. Christin Joy (youngest of four, with 3 older brothers) was born and raised in beautiful Annapolis, MD ““ with the voice of an angel and the compassion to match; she is quite a wonderful singer and writer. The Perfect Place is a Husband/Wife duo that enjoys writing and performing music in their spare time. While their main area of expertise is theologically minded, they have been known to get a little silly from time to time. Masters of Song Fu should prove to be an interesting challenge, one we await with eager anticipation. Woot!

Official Website: www.myspace.com/oneperfectplace
ROUND 1 SONG:If I’ve Learned Anything

HIS NAME IS LEGS

His Name Is Legs is a newly-created rock band comprised of guitarist/vocalist/Song Fu veteran Hazen Nester and bassist Cameron Accola, who collaborated with Nester on two of his previous entries. Born out of a mutual love of Rush and talented musicians in general, His Name Is Legs pledges to provide listeners with an eclectic array of sounds designed to stimulate and elevate. What makes this band unique is that neither Accola nor Nester have ever met each other in person.

Official Website: www.myspace.com/hisnameislegs
ROUND 1 SONG:One Of The Team

lucyline.gif

To download a ZIP FILE containing all of the ROUND 1 songs, CLICK HERE.

[display_podcast]

lucyline.gif

ROUND 1 VOTING

And now, it’s time for that all important voting. For this round, you can choose your TOP 5 FAVORITE Challenger songs. Be sure to choose carefully. VOTING CLOSES AT 11:59pm EST on SUNDAY, MAY 31st. If you are having trouble voting, CLEAR YOUR BROWSER’S CACHE and try again.

lucyline.gif

ROUND 1 VOTING – THE CHALLENGERS

[poll id=”18″]

View Results

lucyline.gif

If you triumph, not only will you win remarkable (and potentially off-putting) bragging rights and a clutch of fantastic mystery prizes, you will also become the proud owner of the magnificent, one-of-a-kind MASTER OF SONG FU TROPHY.

Good luck, and bring on the Fu.

lucyline.gif

[ad#contestbox]

Comments

233 responses to “Masters Of Song Fu #4: Round 1 Challenge Voting Begins!”

  1. Philip Avatar

    First of all…I would like to say that this person doesn’t know what she is talking about…

    (# Sarah Says:
    May 29th, 2009 at 1:04 pm

    Um… wow. Caleb Lee is DEFINITELY cheating! 80+ votes in an hour and a half? Yeah right.

    Totally a cheat.)

    Let me tell you something…CalebLee has a very large following…He has a decent fan base. He has been known for years. He is not cheating. I know for fact that there are tons of people that I had posted this website too personally…just to listen to the songs and see what they thought…and they told me they loved CalebLees song and voted for him. I am telling every friend I know to listen and be fair. Thanks

  2. Lex Vader Avatar

    @jutze – My whole intention was to annoy Jutze until the chorus kicks in! Success!

    @perfectplace AWWWWGHH. I would have tortured a terrorist to hear a song about Jack Bauer’s wristwatch!

    @MiceElf registration would mean greatly reduced traffic and votes. They want to keep it “open.”

    And can I just say my right ear is clogged, so I apologize if my next entry isn’t quite balanced.

    And can I also just say, if Rock Band 2 sponsors this contest, why aren’t they promoting it?

  3. Berg Avatar

    first off…no one admitted to cheating. I flat out said I wan NOT involved. I am saddened that any of my friends would do this however and did apologize.

    Secondly, votes were only taken away from the same IP adress, not randomly.

    @JJ yes lets be friends

    @Carolina I was the one who pointed out this mistake, and I am the one who also lost quite a few votes. And to be honest I am glad that things are fair now. We now have all that votes that we rightfully earned. And I am glad to know that now I am rightfully in the position I am and not ahead because of whoever voted multiple times for me.

    I never blamed Caleb, and am a really big fan of his work. I know that no contestant was behind the forcing of the votes. I never called him a cheater…and never will.

    I think it time that we move on, write songs, get along, and love the creativity that blooms here. That’s it!

    P.S. Negative comments do need to stop…from all ends.

  4. cobra Avatar
    cobra

    I don’t think Berg was admitting to cheating! Yes, he lost votes too, but he obviously found out about the glich in the system and felt it should be reported. If he was cheating, he wouldn’t have reported the glich! Think about it!!!!

    Now, let’s get back to having fun and writing and listening to some great songs!!!!!

    BTW Thanks Berg for making things fair!!

  5. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    Registration or requiring an e-mail address to vote might reduce votes in general, but if the same computer is allowed to vote as much as it wants freely, anyone can just have as many votes as they want, and that’s not fair either.

    So, MiceElf: It’s not wrong that all of them want to vote, but allowing the same IP address multiple times makes it susceptible to cheating… and as we saw it already was.
    (Not saying Caleb shouldn’t get votes from family… but honestly, how is it possible to get over 80 votes in a span of twenty minutes without cheating? The voting system locked up and everything due to flood control… that says something.)
    I voted on my laptop, and my brother voted on my parent’s computer, but my parents weren’t able to vote, so I understand what you’re saying.
    There needs to be a better way to do it, either way. I agree.

  6. Lex Vader Avatar

    I find the best solution is not to have a family.

  7. Aaron Avatar
    Aaron

    It looks to me like EVERYONE has votes missing since the change.
    Berg and Jerry’s votes have been halfed too.

    You can’t blame over eager fans for wanting to help out their favourite entry.

    Could everyone stop bitching now?

    Most of the competitors here have been polite and friendly about the whole ordeal. They seem to have the most level headed responses about it all too.

    It only seems to be a small minority of (from what I can tell) people who aren’t in the competition that are getting so bent out of shape about it, again from what I can see.
    Why are they getting so worked up when the people competing themselves aren’t?

  8. riddle Avatar
    riddle

    quick rundown:
    there was a bug in the voting,
    some visitors exploited it,
    enough to get our attention,
    so the bug was fixed,
    and duplicate votes were removed,
    SO THAT:
    every vote each musician has now is an EARNED vote
    and each musician has all the votes they EARNED.
    period. move on.
    no need for further drama.

  9. Laura Avatar
    Laura

    Oh my god.. so the votes were taken away from everyone?
    This is sad and silly.
    I’m not even going to bother. I told everyone from my network about this site. Many of my friends turned out in about 30 minutes to vote. I know famous authors who have a ton of connections. You all got noticed because of this.
    I’m sad now. I wish I hadn’t told any of them to come here and vote.
    It’s totally unprofessional to accuse someone of cheating when it’s open voting. Reminds me of a former presidential election. All of you are very talented. But you have to work it. Caleb Lee had a huge fanbase and network structure in place before this competition. And he’ll have one after it’s over. I’m just sick, reading all of this. What a total disappointment.

  10. Aaron Avatar
    Aaron

    Well said Riddle

  11. Travis Norris Avatar
    Travis Norris

    A Song Fu #4 Haiku:

    Voting: tempers flare;
    Technology is to blame.
    Ever’body chill.

    🙂

  12. Pat Misterovich Avatar

    Let’s get back to the music. I wanted to give some feedback to all the artists before the voting closed. Overall a very impressive 1st round. I can’t wait for the next challenge.

    @Andrew Jon Thomson: Someplace 2 Land: Great backing band. Nice tune. Lyrics are a bit hard to make out (which for a normal song isn’t that big of a deal but for a contest like this it can be a detriment.) Also a bit long (again only relevant for this contest.) I don’t care that much if it was written in advance. You have been a valuable contributor in the comments and I am looking forward to your round 2 entry.

    @AudioMohel: Hubcap Without a Home: Love the Johnny Cash vibe it fits very well with the lyrics. A nice homage to the car centric songs of the 60’s.

    @Austin Morley: A Record Of Your Life: Reminded me of a 90’s alt rock song. It doesn’t have a big melodic hook. Because of that it hasn’t garnered a lot of attention here. But I do like the concept behind it.

    @Berg and Jerry: Green Potato Chip: Love the melodica. Love the conceit, the idea that the nasty green potato chip stands in for feeling like an outsider. In fact I might actually call it a metaphor song than actually being from the point of view of the chip. But that’s is perfectly ok with me. Plus Berg gets my respect for his honestly and commitment to making sure the contest is fair. Thanks Berg!

    @BHBobby: Noose: Who can’t relate to this one? I would be tempted to push the bass and percussion back in the mix. The melody gets a bit lost since your singing style is not really melodic. But still, I do enjoy this song when it comes around on the ipod.

    @Caleb Hines: Ancient Wonder: Very nice production quality. I like the change into what feels more like a prechorus or maybe a bridge but it doesn’t pay off because there really doesn’t seem to be a real chorus. Lyrically you could have pushed more of a story. I wouldn’t throw this away. I think there is something there but it needs a bit of tweaking.

    @Caleb Lee: Mirror: I could definitely hear this song on the radio. I am quite sure some girls will fall in love with you because of this song. Nice job.

    @Darrell Maclaine: Strawberry Fool: It took the Google for me to figure out that Strawberry Fool was a food dish. Great John Lennon homage. Now that I know what Strawberry Fool is the play on the word Fool is meaningful. Again very John Lennonish.

    @Denise Hudson: Leave the Stone Alone (no yep): I always have to run over to the stereo and turn up the volume so that I can hear the lyrics when this comes around. It’s a shame because it is a nice song. Good voice. Looking forward to your round 2.

    @Derrek J. Thompson: O’ Riely’s Underpants: Is O’ Riely is an intentional misspelling? Very silly song. One of the few songs with a political view point. I would have liked to see Derrek’s brainstorming list for this round. I wonder what ideas he didn’t pursue.

    @Edric Haleen: All For This Moment: Stephen Sondheim would be proud of this. By the way, great vocals and great piano work.

    @Godz Poodlz: Bad Penny: I have come to love Russ but I still hope he loses to a certain group of pre-teens! Great chorus on this song and I completely back your use of Grab a Penny from a Pick a Penny Cup.

    @Gorbzilla: I am Your Pants: One of my favorites this round. I love the combination of the uber macho blues vocals with an object that obviously has some “feelings” for its owner. “Keep Your Junk From Flopping Round” Awesome! ‘Ohhhh listen to those Corduroys” Awesome!

    @Gremlins: Neutron Star: Another favorite. Who would have thought you could develop empathy for a Neutron Bomb. This is one of the songs that I find myself singing in my head when I’m paying attention. The sad part is that I sing the vocal/trumpet solo.

    @His Name is Legs: One of the Team: The 60 cycle hum at the beginning always gets me to twiddle the jack on my ipod until I realize that is the song. For that you will not receive a proper review from me until you apologize!

    @Ian and Melissa: I Remember: I don’t think anyone has commented on the beautiful animation that goes with this song. Nice job. It goes wonderfully with the song. If you haven’t seen it yet, go to http://www.ianandmelissa.com/

    @Jalapeno Habeneros: Aquaman: Some great lyrics on this but the vocals get a little bit lost in the mix. I like the chorus especially.

    @Jarrett Heather: Trapped Inside Your Sofa: Reminds me of a Joe Raposa song. And I mean that as the highest compliment. This is one that got one of my votes.

    @Jeremy Pierson: Your Welcome Mat: Great vibe solo. Not sure if I like the other instruments as much. I wish I could hear the song with a different arrangement or with a full band. I know that isn’t really fair to say but I think the song is pretty good and a full band would make it back.

    @Jutze Schult: Natalie Portman’s Doormat: Reminds me a bit of John Wesley Harding. Am I correct in recognizing references to Beautiful Girls in this?

    @Lex Vader: Just a Rock: I like the synth solo. I like the surprise of the lines “I Don’t Want to Be A Measurement for Your Fat Ass” and “I’d Turn the Tide.”

    @Mike Lombardo Trio: Rock Song: Opening piano reminds me a bit of a song called Sound Scientist from a band named Bill. I’ve always liked that song so Mike Lombardo got my attention immediately with this. Great work by the band.

    @Miles From Nashville: A Bridge To Nowhere: Too bad this round wasn’t last October. This song probably would have stood out more. I do like the Neil Young styled harmonica.

    @The Perfect Place: If I’ve Learned… Nice Indigo Girls style guitar and harmonies. It helps to read the lyrics along with this one because they are a bit hard to hear in the mix.

    @Richard Clayton Spring: Crazy Straw: I look forward to the “My Name is Cup” part every time this one comes up on the playlist. This song would have totally worked in the early 70’s punk scene (Iggy, MC5, Modern Lovers, etc)

    @Sara Parsons: Throw Me Away: Are you really saying that this spork has been used more than once? Some good lines that surprise you. If the spork is taken as a metaphor the song has some deeper meaning that match up well with the tune/arrangement.

    @The Scribbles: Snuggie Like Me: I couldn’t be prouder of my son and his friends. They are wonderful kids who amaze us every day.

    @Steve Chatterton: I Will Always Look Up to You: Reminds me of Blitzen Trapper and that is a very good thing in my mind. I would have never guessed that “I’ve Came from Afghanistan Just to Tie Your Room Together” would stick in my mind. But it does.

    @Tom Milsom: The Raincoat’s Lament: Love the part where the simple Ukulele song breaks into a full pop song. It always surprises me for some reason, in a good way. I like the synth part. I might even suggest to make the synth a bit “dirtier” to offset the sweetness of the song.

    @Travis Norris: Enertronic Bow: I just learned what an e-bow is a few weeks ago so I didn’t have to google this one. I had fun trying to catch all of the references in the song. I suspect you had fun writing this.

  13. Darrel Avatar
    Darrel

    It’s been said that Caleb Lee has a huge following. However, that is NOT the cause of the massive number of votes in such a short time. The votes that were taken away were DUPLICATES from the SAME IP ADDRESS.
    AKA CHEAT VOTES.

    The bug is now fixed. It’s fair now.

    Stop bitching.

  14. Lex Vader Avatar

    @PatMisterovich (oh why did you go and change the meaning of this symbol, TWITTER?) Thank you. I’m glad someone appreciated those three things.

    But did ANYBODY get my joke about the moon? “…no celestial objects (i.e. the sun or the moon.)”

  15. Ashley Scemnez Avatar
    Ashley Scemnez

    It’s been said that Caleb Lee has a huge following. However, that is NOT the cause of the massive number of votes in such a short time. The votes that were taken away were DUPLICATES from the SAME IP ADDRESS.
    AKA CHEAT VOTES.
    So unless all 80 of Caleb’s fans got together in 20 minutes and all voted on the same computer…

    The bug is now fixed. It’s fair now.

    Stop bitching.

  16. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    Can’t everyone just let this go now?

    This is supposed to be fun, right?

  17. Travis Norris Avatar
    Travis Norris

    @Pat Misterovich (Is it Patricia or Patrick?): Thank you for your comments! I did indeed have a lot of fun writing/arranging/recording my song for this round. Let’s hope that keeps up. By the way, if you didn’t notice already, I believe we share a home state! Go Midwestern type people!

  18. Pat Misterovich Avatar
    Pat Misterovich

    Travis, it’s Patrick, but only when I sign my name or do something wrong. We are in Springfield, MO. Where are you?

  19. MiceElf Avatar
    MiceElf

    Caleb has more than 80 members in just his immediate family….but even without taking that into consideration, Caleb Lee is as honest and moral a person as you can find in this day and age. ‘Cheater’ is a character smear that he just does not deserve.
    He will be missing out on a LOT of votes just because not everyone in his family has ‘one computer per each individual’…. if they did, boy would you see the numbers jump up!
    Meanwhile back at the ranch, some of you guys are radically talented and should be on the radio already!

  20. Lex Vader Avatar

    Look, there was an inexplicable time-space anomaly that caused Caleb Lee to get more votes on his song than views on his video. It has never happened before or since. Let’s just be glad we don’t live in the alternate universe where he has a beard and is Emperor of the Galaxy.

  21. Caleb H Avatar
    Caleb H

    @Lex: LOL! I hadn’t realized that line was a joke against the rules, but that makes it even better! I liked the line because for once we get to hear the rock stop complaining about what it DOESN’T want, and share it’s own dreams or ambitions. The Moon seems like a perfectly logical thing for a rock to aspire to (and of course, the punchline: “I’d turn the tide” is awesome).

    Also, please extract “Rock! (ROCK!!) Rock! (ROCK!!)” from my brain immediately. 🙂

  22. Caleb H Avatar
    Caleb H

    (My LOL is in response to Lex’s earlier post explaining the bridge as a joke, not in response to his time-space anomoly post directly above)

  23. Caleb H Avatar
    Caleb H

    @Pat: I don’t think Sarah was actually saying the spork was used more than once. I misunderstood that my first couple times too, then I realized it was probably sarcasm — Go ahead and throw me away, it’s not like this is my first time being used… Oh wait. Yes it is.

    BTW, I get vibes of Coulton’s “I Crush Everything” from this song’s lyrics. The forgotten spork looking for love, but better off lying below, in the bottom of a garbage can.

  24. Travis Norris Avatar
    Travis Norris

    *fake announcer voice* It’s a HEATED race for 21st place, folks! What’ll it be, the guitar STAND, the guitar GADGET or the doesn’t-want-to-be-a welcome mat.. place ya bets, place ya bets…

  25. Caleb Lee Avatar

    @MiceElf – Thank you for the defense sis… it’s cool. It’s been fixed.

    @Ashley Scemnez – There’s no way 80 members of my family would agree to be in the same place, much less use the same computer in just under 20 min.. 😉

    @Lex – I use word of mouth, texts, and e-mails to get my votes… the video was for giggles… HOWEVER I’d like to point out your video is amazing and I’m now a fan of you because of it.

    @Travis Norris – I like your Haiku =)

    @Berg – I agree, lets all move on!

    @Michelle – I hope I haven’t offended you with any of my actions. I also hope I can write a song that you will like.

    @Russ – We don’t get any money?! Well eff that, I’m out! (j/k)

    @EVERYONEELSE – Thanks for voting! (Whoever that vote went to) & Thanks for listening to our collective music!

    Anybody else already obsessing over what round 2 could possibly be????

  26. Caleb Lee Avatar

    @Pat – Girls?! Crap if I’d known that I’d just have tossed this around some.. um… girl.. place. =| Hah.

  27. Travis Norris Avatar
    Travis Norris

    @PatMisterovich: I’m in Kansas City. I’m originally from the Chillicothe area, if you know where that is.

    @CalebLee: Yes. I’m obsessesed. That’s why I won’t shut up on this page :p (Also, I got like two hours of sleep due to a work shift mixup and I’m riding a massive caffeine high to not flop down face first on my keyboard, wheeeee) Thanks for liking my Haiku. *lol*

    @Lex: A beard? You sure it isn’t a goatee or a *Shudder!* soul patch?

  28. Berg Avatar

    @CalebLee…I’m REALLY hoping for a a country song, because its prolly my least favorite genre, and would LOVE to tackle it.

  29. The Perfect Place (Bud) Avatar

    i am too, caleb (lee)! lol.

  30. Jutze Avatar

    @TravisNorris: My comments were written during the listening session, so I was always distracted by chat and the songs. Then yours was one of the last ones played; it was already 3.30 am local time – anyway, what I mean with “lack of ambition” is definitely not the ambition of you as a musician. I rather mean the (absence of) encouragement of any sort in the song. Often songs are implicitly or explicitly saying “Dance!” “Smile!” “Die!” “Heal the world!” or like Lex’s “ROCK!” Radiohead-ish music often is like “well, dunno, whatever.”
    The repetitive guitar picking line part is kind of the signature in your song. It’s not what I’d call a hookline. Still, it serves the song, which to me is sort of a history lesson on the ebow, which is along with the Mellotron one of the things I want to make music with some day. So yeah, the lyrics… are good, very good. They’re not what I called “encouraging”, but still “did you know?” – and “did you know?” is something I rather enjoy. Plus, your vocals really suit the style of music.

    @Pat: And if his song won’t make girls fall in love with Caleb Lee, it might still make mirrors fall in love with him. As for “Beautiful Girls” references in my song: if you recognize them, I’m positive they’re there.

    @LexVader and all: Rock (ROCK) Rock (ROCK)!

    PS: I think I could make an additional voting (for fun) for the next where you can rate lyrics/producton/vocals/challenge-compliance/creativity/looks/song length/dancability; after all, data collection and analysis is how I make a living.

  31. Laura Avatar
    Laura

    Well, none of us are able to vote again. So I don’t know if my vote was counted or not. When I first voted Caleb Lee had 108 votes. It won’t let me or any of my friends vote now.
    So I guess it’s ‘fixed’ alright.
    I’m totally embarrassed and I won’t be telling any of my friends to come here and listen and vote again.

  32. Denise Hudson Avatar

    I know that my humble, tiny rock has mysterious powers
    (and is low in the voting results
    {smile})
    BUT … it is still, nonetheless – a rock. So there are actually THREE rocks (and thusly, three rock songs) in this competition. And, I hasten to say, all quality tunes. Now I am a silly stone, but clearly do refer to myself as rock in the first stanza (and in other places).
    Cheers, and have a pleasant, rocking day
    Magma-namiously
    DH

  33. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    No hard feelings, Caleb. Just a tough crowd. 😉

  34. Denise Hudson Avatar

    Also … I have FINALLY read through … ALL of the comments.
    I wipeth my brow.
    Thank you to the twitterers who have joined my small gathering 🙂
    Particularly since I didn’t publicize my account.
    Thanks to Jutze and P Misterovich. I’m in total agreement with your comments; except that I am somewhat stuck with my excessive soul, as I am a southerner living in a hot climate.
    To Mr. Mister…ovich (I can’t resist, I suck) – I’m not sure what your song was, if you were contesting this round. All songs had redeeming qualities though, so you did a good job if you were in it.
    To Jutze, your song was great great great!
    I am going to learn how to master and normalize before submitting the next entry, now that I have learned that this is a cumulative thing …

    DH

    PS. The only thing that beats the common and boring rock in ‘rock-paper-scissors’ is paper; that bearer of rock-dismissin’ comments, and which can be set on fire by rock magic 😉

  35. Kay Avatar
    Kay

    What is this? you’ve got to be kidding, He’s got a big fan following, That is not cheating! you wont even let us re put in our votes, that is such BS.

    These contests are Biest, picking favorites.
    He was obviously not cheating you just wanted whoever you wanted to win so you accused him of it.

    Very immature.

  36. Berg Avatar

    @ Kay/other Caleb Lee fans that wont read!

    Please stop this nonsense already. There was an issue with people voting multiple times. The votes were put back to one vote per computer.

    And the voting is CONSTANTLY freezing. Its not like it knows when a Caleb Lee fan is coming on a goes “OOH NOES! NOW MY FAVORITE WONT WIN. BlOCk ThE VoTeS!!!!”

    Me and Caleb both said that this needs to stop NOW!

    We are the ones in the competition that this effected the most, and we have both accepted this, now please STOP TALKING ABOUT THIS ISSUE!

    In other news….I can’t get Trapped Inside Your Sofa out of my head…Err sooooooooo catchy!

  37. Steve Chatterton Avatar

    @Pat Misterovich: Sorry about the ear bug thing. I once played a demo to a friend who grabbed me by the neck (comically) frustrated that she couldn’t get the chorus of that tune out of her head.

    It’s always nice to hear I remind someone of another artist in a good way, especially when I’ve never heard of them (if they’re huge, please forgive me – I pretty much live directly under a rock).

    Thanks for your kind words. Must go hunt down some Blitzen Trapper now. Thanks.

    Also, I’m digging the detailed all-inclusive feedback posts. It brings this almost to the realm of a songwriters’ circle. I think we should all, as participants, do that from now on (um, starting with the next one, ’cause, uh, I’ve got a really busy weekend ahead of me, ya know).

    Oh, and Laura, you’re taking this all way too seriously. Several of my friends haven’t been able to vote from day one, but I’ve never complained. And your comments about how huge Caleb L’s following is makes it sound like a) he’s pretty much a household name, b) he should be competing at the Master level, not as a Challenger, and c) the rest of us are a bunch of lazy no talent god-for-nothings that put no effort into networking and don’t have anyone who would vote for them anyway.

    Personally, I’ve been honing my craft for an embarrassingly long time (I’m sure many of my cohorts were in diapers when I penned my first tune – except for the Scribbles, who weren’t even born yet) and I’ve slowly been building my own fan-base since I started playing clubs in the late 80’s and worked my way through jazz school in the 90’s. Sure, I’ve kept a pretty low profile over the last few years as I’ve dedicated myself to being a stay-at-home dad, but I still have a strong mailing list (get on it, why don’t ya: http://www.stevechatterton.com/mailing-list), I blog whenever I can with much more frequent posts to come when my son starts school in September (http://www.stevechatterton.com/), and I’m no stranger to social media either (follow me on Twitter: http://twitter.com/SteveChatterton – or ask to be my friend on Facebook, or join my Facebook fan page: http://www.new.facebook.com/pages/Steve-Chatterton/30875471639). I’ve even got a MySpace page, http://www.myspace.com/stevechatterton, which I haven’t been using, but will now that I see the kind of traffic it can generate, as well as a YouTube account which I’m going to get serious about any day now: http://www.youtube.com/user/SteveChattertonMusic (the new MacBook has a web-cam built in!).

    And I’m pretty sure a lot of the other competitors have also made a huge effort too.

    Get it? We all have gifts, we all have family (maybe not as prolific as some), we all have friends, and we’re all trying hard, but I don’t think any of us are obsessed about the points as much as you are, which is really, really strange. They really don’t matter. I don’t know how else to get that point across.

    We’re here to share music. That’s all.

  38. xtianna Avatar

    @kay: your vote wasn’t removed… so of course you cant “revote” and caleb lee wasnt the only one who lost votes
    inside every computer is a magical number that lets the internet know which computer is doing what (oh hey, uncle sam!) this number was encoded in our votes… any votes that were cast by that same magical number (ip address) were removed so only 1 per ip address were left

    @caleb lee: i am obsessing about it

    @everyone: lets give it a rest… no one meant for this to happen and now its fixed… PLEASE move on already

    @lex: let’s be friends 😀

  39. Travis Norris Avatar
    Travis Norris

    *rolls Will vs. Cave into escalating negative energy… 20+3=23 DC=22 SUCCESS!*

    Ahem. If you understood that, you are a nerd.

    WARNING: This. Is. Long.
    —————————

    And now some thoughts. I’ll try not to echo the others who did a full rundown too much.

    @Andrew Thompson — I’ve never been too much of a fan of political songs that are so specific in their content; reason being that the song stops or greatly decreases being relevant in 5 or 10 years. As mentioned, the track is a bit long for my tastes. The lyrics (once we look past the problem above) are clever but there are lots of them–all the jamming is great but there is a lot of it. One or the other (or both) need to be pared down a bit. Play the super extended version live, I guarantee they’ll eat it up. *grin*

    @Audiomohel — It’s corny outlaw country… and I flipping love it (maybe because I live almost directly beneath I-29?) I’d recruit a steel player to throw in some lead stuff and try to sell this to people who like Cake’s “Stickshifts and Safety Belt”

    @Austin & The Pudaks — Ah, that great alt/emo quality of being simultaneously depressing and nostalgic and hopeful. I think this song deserves more votes. Some kind of percussion, maybe even a hand drum or a quiet tambourine, would really fill the track out. One of the strongest lyrical entries, I feel. “…those horrible dance moves are coming out”

    @Buckethat Bobby — My first thought was “Daniel Johnston?!” (Disclaimer: I haven’t actually heard much Daniel Johnston, so maybe I’m way off, but still) But in the sense of the vocal delivery, minimal instrumentation, and whimsical yet everyman subject matter… yeah. Enjoy it more every time I hear it.

    @Caleb H — Like I said at the listening party, I was impressed with the instrumentation and the thought-outed-ness of that various parts. I somewhat disagree that the song doesn’t have a hook–it’s more that the “hook” is a little to short to set the line as it were and is only repeated a few times. See Godz Poodlz for the example of how to set the line. 😀 I’d like to reiterate; sweet solos (coming from a guy who is traditionally not the biggest wind fan).

    @Darrel Maclaine: Well, the Beatle-ousity of the track has been well remarked on by this time, so I’ll just say that the hardest part of a Beatles homage is the overall production and pitch-perfect vocals and you succeeded famously on those points. I wanted a weird, backwards tape guitar solo in there… but I would, wouldn’t I?

    @Denise Hudson: Hey has anyone told you your track is too quiet? Sorry, couldn’t resist. That is one sassy stone you’re singing about there. I say wave your Southern Soul flag proudly, we could use a little more around here. I would say there are too many lyrics (contributing to the song being a bit on the long side) but the lyrics are quite clever, so I’d rather not. I’d also say the bridge goes on to long, but I like it, so I’m not going to say that either. In short… make the track louder next time 😉 Solo guitar worked pretty well for this track (especially with the layered vocals), but any chance of more instruments on future entries?

    @Derrek Thompson — I think you easily have the most misunderstood track this go around…. because we can’t understand what you’re saying. Which is a shame because the few lyrics that I can make out seem pretty hilarious (“we’ll do it live!”). Did you post lyrics? I can’t find them, but this page is getting pretty hard to navigate. I assume that the somewhat.. eccentric nature of the vocals is intentional. Probably not something I’d try again. The music was cheery and catchy in a Mountain Goats sort of way, so that’s good.

    @Edric — First of all I wanted to say I appreciate your very POSITIVE influence on the goings on around here, we certainly need it lately. Most everything I’ve heard from you sounds like it would fit well in (insert name of broadway show here), which is awesome. Following that, I think I would enjoy most of it more in the context of a show (I’m not one of those people who listens to musical soundtracks outside of the musical, regardless of how much I like it). BTW, I’m totally with you on the “hugging vs. some other lyric” thing. 😀

    @Godz Poodlz: Is that TMBG? Musically, lyrically, and production-wise I seriously would think it was them if I didn’t know it was GODZ POODLZ (sorry, too lazy for umlauts). I hope thats as big a comment to you as it would be to me. And the chorus is stuck to the top of my skull, I think. Thanks a lot. 😀

    @Gremlins — Great vocals, I wish the production quality matched them (please don’t take that the wrong way). Honestly, it’s a freaking sci-fi epic with banjos. I was pretty much sold 30 seconds in. I do think the skat bit would be better left to a live setting, or if you had some kind of lead instrument playing the notes with vocals coming and going around it that would be better. But I think you already talked about that. Whee… yes. Good song.

    @His Name is Legs: I love the lo-fi-ness of the track. The vocals could be a little better (yeah, I know, I should talk) pitchwise, but on the plus size this is definitely among the most easily understood vocals this round. Also the melody sits in a strange (strange like intriguing, not like bad) place between major and minor keys to my ear. I like the guitar solos.. reverbilicious.. I like the various references to classic rock songs as well. You manage to get quite a bit of jamming in without cracking 4 minutes. Nice!

    @Ian and Melissa: The vocals are a touch too low (especially when they’re so pretty). The guitar is maybe slightly too warm/bassy, I think it would have sounded slightly better if it had been doubletracked and then the two parts panned to opposite sides of the stereo spectrum, or maybe with an acoustic bass quietly playing roots (if you are actually doing either of those things and I’m just not hearing it.. well… I’m an idiot) But that is kind of a pain in the butt when you’re working on a limited time table. Like Jutze said, it has a very soundtrack-like feel, which is good. Ending is mysteriously sudden. All in all, very solid.

    @Jarret Heather: I like all the little touches and general attention to detail (video game noises when mentioning DK for instance). Definitely one the cleanest tracks as far as playing. And happily the production quality matches! It reminds me of Ben Folds (sorry, you’re probably tired of hearing that) but it’s different enough it doesn’t sound like a rip-off (or an homage, either, hehe). Love the bridge on basis of the last line alone. Probably my favorite chorus of the round.

    @Jeremy Pierson: Grooove. That was my first thought. The vibes solos are great. Harmonies on the chorus… thumbs up. Great bass playing too, really nails down the low end and grooves. And good lyrics too! Ends somewhat suddenly (which I assume was an attempt to keep it short for the benefit of the listeners). All in all, I’m surprised you don’t have more votes and can only assume it’s because of the somewhat 80s-ish nature of the instrumentation. But hell, I like it. Heh.

    @Jutze: Truly, I feel bad for this non-creature who gets kicked around by one of the most criminally adorable actresses of our generation. Simple, short, and sweet, and references the death of a dog to get that deciding tug of the heartstrings in. Good stuff.

    @Lex Vader: Rock!… Rock!…. yeah, we were singing BGVs in the listening party, did anyone tell you that? Yeah, we were. Probably the funniest lyrics of the round (I especially like the bits that reference the rules of the competition). As you might have guessed from my own (much less professional) production I really enjoyed all the layered complimentary guitar parts, and those keyboards (I assume that’s what they are?). The “don’t want to be a measurement for your fat ass” part almost made my girlfriend spit soda out her nose, so well done there. Looking forward to your next entry.

    @Mike Lombardo: Your song is very good. Next! No, just kidding. Although I don’t have a lot more to add, I just wanted to comment on the “pre-written song” thing. Your song fit the criteria of the round perfectly so I have a hard time begrudging the entry. I don’t know what kind of program Berklee has (I hear it’s pretty good!) but I assume you have stacks of songs that may have been “challenges” of a very Song Fu-like nature from your instructors. I really have a hard time blaming you wanting to make sure somebody else hears them.

    @Miles From Nashville: The harmonica (unless it’s a melodica, which will make me look like a stupid earless person) saves this song from losing me between verses. The lyrics are pretty good but the song is just a little slow for my taste (this could have also been the number of songs I had already been through before I got to your entry). Like Pat said, probably would have done better back in early October or so.

    @Molly: Where are you? (I Pity The Fool just came on somehow.)

    @Richard Clayton Spring — I feel ashamed to say I didn’t like your song at first. I know feel like the least fun person in the universe. The lo-fi, early punk-like nature of the song makes me smile, as do the lyrics once I paid enough attention to them. I rock out to the end everytime I hear it now.

    @Sara Parsons — That is quite a voice you have. The harmonies are really nice too. The very sweet vibe of the music contrats in a good way with the ironic/sarcastic content of the lyrics. And in a random comment, however you miked the acoustic is the right way to do it. (This is something that is difficult to appreciate before you have to mic an acoustic yourself, so trust me, people, it’s like an advanced science) Good job!

    @The Scribbles — Fellow Missourians unite! I had to look up what a Snuggie is. I am not trendy. I like the gradual pitch shift on “what do you thiiiiink”. The fact that you wrote a song that meets the requirements of the final round of last edition and has a -story arc- is pretty impressive. I like the blanket chorus. Okay, I think you get it. I really like this song. 🙂

    @Steve Chatterton — the vaguely CSN&Y vocals are really awesome on this one. The handclaps are a nice touch (never can make them work in my own songs.. :() And the chorus is right up there with Lex and da Poodlz for stuck-in-my-head-edness. Finally, any song that manages a Big Lebowski reference and mentions Afghanistan so cheerfully is good in my book.

    @Tom Milson — Like some others, the topic of the Raincoat just doesn’t really resonate with me. But I do enjoy how it turns into a full band production after the first verse/chorus, and the chorus is pretty catchy for no longer/no more words than it contains. Very solid song and I can see why you’re YouTube Famous. I have a suspicion this song is probably going to grow on me with a few more listens.

    @Berg & Jerry — Love the melodica and the somewhat unconventional melody/chord progression in the verses. I want drums/fullband when the doubletime part comes in. A little cleaner recording would be great too but in testament to the quality of the song itself the production isn’t really a big detterent. In a way the sort of break-uppy sound of the guitar gives it some lo-fi character and cred.

    @CalebLee — The first song I heard (via the Myspace) and I thought “I am really in trouble if everybody else’s song is this good”. This song is pretty much radio ready (re-recorded for production concerns); would probably do equally well with full band and unplugged versions. Great lyrics, great melody/harmony. And obviously you have a devoted legion of fans to get the word out. 🙂

    @Gorbzilla — i like the The Band vibe of the track. Lyrics are occasionally difficult to understand which is unfortunate because the ones I can understand are hilarious. (“…keep your junk from flopping around…”) I say you kidnap a drummer for next run. Or kidnap a drum kit. Or both. I think you should have traded fours between the corduroy and a twangy Telecaster, also.

    @Jalapeno Haberneros — Reminded me of Jack Johnson. And then stopped. Unfortunately I just can’t make the lyrics out and can barely hear the vocals period so it’s pretty much a strumfest. Unfortunate, because I like comic book references. Turn the vox up a bit next round, eh?

    @The Perfect Place — Reminds me of a band called Caedmon’s Call (this is a good thing). The absence of low end in the recording greatly decreases the appeal of the song as it all sounds a bit tinny… so it is a testament to how well your voices go together that I can still listen to the whole thing. Speaking of which, good job budgeting your time between instrumental and lyrical moments. Very clever lyrics, and enough musical variation to keep either thing from getting boring. (And I can relate to getting attached to the first idea you had for the inanimate object. I unfortunately couldn’t think of anything else after my mind lit on the happy subject of the Ebow.)

    Phhhheewwww. Okay, that’s it. (If I missed you, let me know and I will CRITIQUE THE HELL OUT OF YOU) Hopefully nobody minds the epic length of this post too much.

    Can’t wait for Tuesday! 🙂

  40. Travis Norris Avatar
    Travis Norris

    @Jutze: Ah, yes, I see what you mean. LOL. Thom Yorke: “Dance.. if you want to.. or don’t.. anything we play that is danceable is due to sheer IRONY…”

    Glad you liked(?) the guitar figure. I “wrote” the verse melody while at work and the riff after I got home and got my hands on a guitar. Everything else fell into play almost suspiciously easily from there.

    I always wanted to try a Mellotron out too!

  41. Mike McAllister Avatar
    Mike McAllister

    Wow, the voting engine is hung, twitter is in fail whale status … are these signs of the coming aporkalypse? Thanks for the songs, I’ve been enjoying them. 🙂

  42. Caleb H Avatar
    Caleb H

    @Travis in KC, and Pat in Springfield:
    Another Missourian here, from the other side of the state – St. Louis. It seems the Song Fu is strong with Missouri this time.

    @Caleb Lee & everyone else whose hyped about the round starting, but who may have missed Ken’s listening party… The announcement was made that the next round will be announced Monday. (I’m announcing an announcement of an upcoming announcement… what?)

  43. Michelle Avatar
    Michelle

    Last time: The only votes that were removed came from the same IP address.
    JEEZ. IT’S OLD ALREADY.

    I really hope the next challenge isn’t country, because it’d be too painful to listen to and vote on… sorrys.

  44. Hazen of His Name Is Legs Avatar

    @PatMisterovich — We didn’t intend confusion through the hum, however we stand by our instrumentation.

  45. Rogue Bohemian Avatar
    Rogue Bohemian

    Alright, so I thought I should post lyrics to Aquaman’s Trident song, since our mic didn’t quite pick up the vox. Thankfully, we’re getting a new condenser mic, so we should have a better leveled recording next time.
    Thank you for the comments that have been posted so far though.

    Aquaman’s Trident’s Lament

    I’m ready to go
    But you leave me behind
    Did you just forget me?
    Am I at the back of your mind?

    You think that your fish friends
    Help you more than I can
    But what can a dolphin do
    That I can’t in your hands?

    I just want to be used by you
    I just want you to show that you care
    I believe we have something special
    But this shunning is more than I can bear

    Stop being Superman’s bitch
    Take control of the league
    You could take him down in one fell swoop
    If you just used me

    He may have lasers, super strength, and x-ray vision
    But he doesn’t have unstoppable lightning
    Then stab him through the heart, and then you can start
    Your quest for the world’s enlightening

    I just want to be used by you
    I just want you to show that you care
    I believe we have something special
    But this shunning is more than I can bear

  46. Lex Vader Avatar

    CALEB LEEEEE… at least there’s no suspense about you winning, since all your fans have boycotted the competition due to your mistweet. And also because Molly’s next submission will get 600 votes.

    “Anybody else already obsessing over what round 2 could possibly be????”
    If the challenge is to write a song about how Ken comes up with the challenges, prepare to hear the most effed-up song you’ve ever heard. Heck, I might just write it anyway.

  47. The Perfect Place (Bud) Avatar

    @travis norris: thanks for the comments! i don’t particularly enjoy caedmon’s call, but i know what you mean when you say we remind you of them. ;-D there are many similarities. about the recording… it was recorded in a bedroom with a canon powershot digital camera, hence the poor production value. ;-P i didn’t really have the time or resources for anything better at the time, but i assure you the next few will be much higher in quality. cheers!

  48. Austin & The Pudaks (Austin) Avatar

    @Travis: Thanks for the comments, though I’m not sure I agree with any music I’m involved in being described as emo. I agree that we could have used some percussion, but while we have a ton of guitars available, percussive equipment is nowhere to be found.

    @Pat: This song was written entirely by Jeremy, as I was dealing with a death in the family when the challenge was posted. As such, he also did the vocals. Can you tell he has been listening to a lot of Bob Dylan lately? I think that’s the vocal style he tends to aim for. The next song will likely sound entirely different and possibly have a change of vocalist.

  49. riddle Avatar
    riddle

    my prediction for next challenge: write a song in which every word in the song (except for articles or prepositions) starts with the same letter.

  50. Caleb H Avatar
    Caleb H

    An Artfully Alliterative Anthem? Awesome!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *